Subscribe to New Scientist magazine
ARTICLE

Hope dims that Earth will survive Sun's death

  • 19:09 22 February 2008
  • NewScientist.com news service
  • Jason Palmer
Printable versionEmail to a friendRSS FeedSyndicate
 
When the Sun expands into a red giant several billion years from now, the Earth will be dragged into its atmosphere to a fiery demise, a new study argues (Illustration: Mark Garlick/HELAS)
When the Sun expands into a red giant several billion years from now, the Earth will be dragged into its atmosphere to a fiery demise, a new study argues (Illustration: Mark Garlick/HELAS)
 

The future looks bright for the Earth – but not in the way we’d hoped. The slim chance our planet will survive when the Sun begins its death throes has been ruled out.

In a few billion years, the Sun will fuse the last of its hydrogen into helium, turn into a red giant and expand to 250 times its current size. At first, the Sun’s loss of mass will loosen its gravitational pull on Earth, which will allow the planet to migrate to a wider orbit about 7.6 billion years from now.

This process has led some to speculate that the Earth might escape destruction – but survival now seems impossible, says Peter Schröder of the University of Guanajuato in Mexico and Robert Smith of the University of Sussex in the UK.

They created the most detailed model to date of the Sun’s transition to a red giant, based on observations of six nearby red giant stars. Sure enough, they found that Earth’s orbit will widen at first. But Earth will also induce a “tidal bulge” on the Sun’s surface, with its own gravitational pull. The bulge will lag just behind the Earth in its orbit, slowing it down enough to drag it to a fiery demise.

There is one last hope for anybody still living on Earth, the researchers say. In the past, some have suggested that Earth’s orbit could be tweaked by arranging the fly-by of a nearby asteroid to tug at it. This method could potentially maintain Earth’s speed enough to keep it in a widening orbit, they say.

Journal reference: Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society (DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2008.13022.x)

 
Comment subject
Comment
No HTML except lower case italic tags or lower case bold tags, please:
<i> or <b>
Your name
Your email
 

We need your email in case we need to contact you about the comment. We will not use it for any other purpose.

 
 
There are 90 comments on 7 pages
1  | 
2  | 
3  | 
4  | 
5  | 
6
 | Next
 | Most Recent
 | See all

Why? So What!!

By Jeff Dionne

Fri Feb 22 19:19:24 GMT 2008

Why do we spend money on reseach like this, which would not effect anyone, and cannot even be proven.

We should spend time on money on reseach that would accually improve life for the people of earth!

To me this just Science Fiction!

REPORT | REPLY

Why? So What!!

By Dan

Fri Feb 22 20:01:59 GMT 2008

I suppose someone on the Titanic could have said, "Why do we spend money on iceberg reseach, which would not effect anyone, and cannot even be proven. We should spend time on money accually improving life for the passengers of the Titanic!"

REPORT | REPLY

Why? So What!!

By Jeff Dionne

Mon Feb 25 21:45:36 GMT 2008

What does the Titanic (sunkin boat) and an iceburg(something real!) have anything to do with 7 billion years into a Sci-fi future?

REPORT | REPLY

Why? So What!!

By Anon

Tue Feb 26 03:03:29 GMT 2008

Because earth is like a ship we are all on?

And ice-bergs are just placeholders for your doom of choice. Either way it looks more like doom, if you don't get toasted you might freeze. ...

1 more reply »

REPORT | REPLY

Why? So What!!

By Ed Tarbster

Wed Feb 27 14:54:42 GMT 2008

It's a SUNKEN ship and it's an analogy, likening one thing to another to prove a point ^__^ I think it's an interesting story due to the fact that one day, a long time from now our sun will burn out causing it to become a red giant. Hopefully we'll have colonised other solar systems or inhabitable planets by then, but if not, we're boned (well, whatever creatures, if any, that live on earth will be boned.) Good luck to them. >__<

REPORT | REPLY

Why? So What!!

By Shaun Steenkamp

Fri Feb 22 21:01:58 GMT 2008

Ok, imagine for a moment it's a 1000 years in the future, and the human race is starting to colonise planets in other star systems. Wouldn't you expect this research to help in deciding whether or not a certain planet will survive that stars demise which might be on the order of a million years instead of a few billion? (Take into account the cost of colonisation, a planet will be a huge investment, you'll need to know if it will survive).

All research we do on our own star, and how it works and dies will help in the not too distant future, just because our sun will survive for a few billion years yet, doesn't mean that the research is not applicable to a comparable star out there in it's final stages of life.

REPORT | REPLY

Why? So What!!

By Jeff Dionne

Mon Feb 25 21:50:20 GMT 2008

In a 1000 years nothing we are doing now is going to matter much.

By then if the human race doesn't annihilate it self I am sure our science can handle it then, we haven't even sent another man to the moon in 30 years, never mind colonizing another planet

REPORT | REPLY

Why? So What!!

By Windy

Sat Feb 23 16:58:34 GMT 2008

Because in the process of studying the sun's demise, they are also learning more about the sun and how it behaves in its death throes.

That could be extremely important information someday, even if only to provide early warning of a impending threat.

REPORT | REPLY

Why? So What!!

By Luis Figo

Tue Apr 01 04:10:59 BST 2008

Its amazing to know the earth, the universe and understand astronomy... It is not science fiction it is true... The earth is going to desapear when the sun becomes a red gigant.... Me you or anybody we all are going to die. But the knowlege to whats is really going to happen is a good knowledge... The article is amazing!

REPORT | REPLY

Earth Will Have Been Lifeless For Eons

By Lindsay

Fri Feb 22 20:33:56 GMT 2008

Come now - What has happened to wonder and curiosity? I am just grateful to live in a society where people can explore and wonder and find out things!

There's nothing wrong with adding to our species body of knowlege.

Isn't the Earth going to undergo a run away greenhouse process in about one billion years time? The ever relentless increase in solar luminosity over the suns lifetime means that by about then even a trace component of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere will raise planetary temperatures to the extent that the oceans will begin evaporating. The water molecules will themselves further enhance the super greenhouse effect in positive feedback loop. Solar radiation will also disassociate water molecules high in the atmosphere and the hydrogen will leak into space. The planet will inexorably loose its water. That means for about six billion years before the sun goes red giant the Earth will be a lifeless bone dry Venus-like oven. I doubt anything then around our solar system will be too flustered if the Earth does get swallowed in the end but it should be quite sight to behold.

REPORT | REPLY

You're Kidding, Right?

By Darkblak

Fri Feb 22 20:44:22 GMT 2008

At least two university researchers actually spent time, and no doubt grant money, to come up with a no-brainer conclusion about something that won't happen for 7.6 BILLION YEARS?? Well, congratulations!

How can I sign up for grant money to study such worthy and time-appropriate natural phenoms?

I'm embarrassed that I have even wasted my time reading and posting to this...or yours.

REPORT | REPLY

You're Kidding, Right?

By Lindsay

Fri Feb 22 21:37:34 GMT 2008

Yeah - Thats right they did! That's what they are studying and good for them. By the way at most universities these days students pay through the teeth....or is that the nose?

REPORT | REPLY

You're Kidding, Right?

By Lunatic Fringe

Fri Feb 22 21:54:09 GMT 2008

A good angle for you would be - What happens to the moon? You should go for it!

REPORT | REPLY

You're Kidding, Right?

By Enthralled Peasant

Mon Mar 03 09:13:28 GMT 2008

Methinks the moon will be lost long before then. It will have migrated outward beyond the earth's hill sphere and have entered into a solar orbit.

REPORT | REPLY

You're Kidding, Right?

By James

Tue Mar 04 02:15:05 GMT 2008

People may thinks it is pointless research, but as far i can see knowledge in one field brings advancement in other fields. Thats why you have non stick frypan and easy wash paint, because of NASA.

REPORT | REPLY

You're Kidding, Right?

By Gilbert

Fri Apr 04 12:30:21 BST 2008

Me thinks that me no understandz whats the hellz u guyz are talkings about. So me gonna say that the earthzz is going to blow up with the sun because of the intensorosity of the blow. Good Night.

REPORT | REPLY

There are 90 comments on 7 pages
1  | 
2  | 
3  | 
4  | 
5  | 
6
 | Next
 | Most Recent
 | See all

All comments should respect the New Scientist House Rules. If you think a particular comment breaks these rules then please use the "Report" link in that comment to report it to us.

If you are having a technical problem posting a comment, please contact technical support.

Printable versionEmail to a friendRSS FeedSyndicate
Cover of latest issue of New Scientist magazine
  • For exclusive news and expert analysis every week subscribe to New Scientist Print Edition
  • For what's in New Scientist magazine this week see contents
  • Search all stories
  • Contact us about this story
  • Sign up for our free newsletter
 
PASSWORD LOGIN
username:
password:
 help
SUBSCRIPTIONS
Subscribe to New Scientist magazine